A vital education is crucial if you want your children to succeed in life and find satisfying employment after graduation.
Your kids will be better prepared to deal with the escalating cost of higher education if you start saving for their college days as early as possible.
A 529 plan is a state-sponsored, tax-advantaged education investment account. It is one of the most common ways to save for a child’s postsecondary education.
Using a 529 plan to save money for college and earn tax-free interest can seem obvious, but this isn’t necessarily the best course of action.
This article will discuss the benefits and downsides of Section 529 plans and other viable options for securing your children’s financial future in higher education.
What is a 529 plan, and how does it function?
A 529 plan can either be an investment vehicle or a prepayment vehicle for future education expenses.
Your contributions to a 529 plan grow tax-deferred; if used to pay for qualified higher education expenses, withdrawals from the plan are free of federal income tax.
Prepaid tuition plans allow you to lock in today’s tuition rates for your child’s enrollment at participating schools and universities.
Investing in a prepaid tuition plan is similar to investing in a savings plan because your money will increase over time, and any gains will be exempt from taxation. However, prepaid tuition programs do not cover living expenses like food or housing.
If you’re unsure which college your child will attend, a savings plan is a good bet, especially if you open the account while they’re still young.
Why choosing to invest in a 529 plan might not be a wise choice
So a 529 plan looks like an obvious winner, right? No, that’s not always the case. You and your child’s future financial security may be at risk if you invest in a 529 plan. This is why:
Your child must pay for college with the money
It might seem like a moot argument since the whole idea of starting a 529 plan is to save money for your kid’s college tuition, but that’s not the case.
However, what if they choose not to continue their education beyond high school? On the other hand, what if they enroll in a local institution far more affordable than the private university you’ve been planning on sending them to?
In either event, you’ll have an excess of funds in your 529 plan and will be subject to a 10% fine on any interest generated on those funds.
While the 10% fee on your initial contribution will be waived, the charge on your interest will significantly reduce your returns.
It will restrict your potential investing choices
When you open a 529, you’ll have to choose an investing strategy among the ones provided by the plan.
Options may be limited or unavailable depending on where you live or who you go through to open an account. The variety of choices may not be sufficient to fulfill your long-term investment needs.
Roth IRAs and other brokerage accounts typically have a wider variety of investment opportunities.
It’s crucial to consider before committing to a specific 529 plan, as you might find one that better suits your needs in another state.
You may be required to pay high fees
The fees associated with 529 plans are typically more significant than those of other investment vehicles, such as mutual funds.
The investing firm Vanguard reports that the median expense ratio for 529 plans is 0.40%. That’s about twice as much as the typical expense ratio for a basic mutual fund, which is 0.20%.
If you invest in a 529 plan rather than a mutual fund, you will pay $2 in fees for every $1,000 you put in.
While that may not seem like much, it can add up quickly if you plan to invest the maximum in your child’s 529 plan every year, which could reduce the returns you receive.
It may diminish your child’s prospects of receiving financial aid
Suppose a relative or friend of the family is considering starting a 529 program for your child. In that case, you might suggest they look into other options instead.
Your child’s eligibility for grants, subsidized loans, and work-study programs may be affected by distributions from a 529 plan held by a third party because these payouts are considered untaxed income.
To avoid having a 529 distribution affect your child’s eligibility for Federal Student Aid (FAFSA), you should make sure the individual opening the account is aware of and prepared to follow all necessary procedures.
Other options besides a 529 plan
If you’re looking to start a college savings plan for your kids but aren’t sure if a 529 is the best option, consider these other options.
If you are an experienced investor, a brokerage account may be preferable to a 529 college savings plan.
Investments like stocks, bonds, cryptocurrency, and futures can all be bought using a brokerage account.
Even though there are no tax benefits to utilizing a brokerage account to save for your child’s education, a well-balanced portfolio can outperform a 529 plan in terms of returns.
While commissions and other expenses are standard with many brokerage accounts, some modern brokerage applications will let you trade as much as you like at no extra cost.
Income Retirement Accounts for Working Professionals (Roth IRAs)
A Roth IRA is another choice for saving for your child’s college education.
Although a Roth IRA is designed to help you prepare for retirement, you can use your money tax-free to cover your child’s higher education costs without paying the usual 10% penalty.
Suppose you’re thinking of going this route. In that case, you should talk to a financial planner beforehand to ensure you know all the requirements and contribution limits associated with Roth IRAs.
You can use your child’s college money in a high-yield savings account or a certificate of deposit (CD).
You can use the savings account for whatever you like to help your child, but it won’t yield as much as a 529 plan would.
You can help them out in any way you like, even if they choose to skip college and establish a business, and you won’t have to pay the 10% penalty that comes with a 529 plan.
Instead of a 529 plan, a custodial account like a UGMA (Uniform Gift to Minors Act) or UTMA (Uniform Transfer to Minors Act) would be preferable if you have doubts about your child’s postsecondary plans (Uniform Transfer to Minors Act).
There are no restrictions on how your child may spend the money so long as it is utilized for the child’s benefit under either of these plans, which are regular tax breaks for those under 18. The money in your child’s account will remain under your care until they reach the age of majority (18 for UGMAs, 21 for UTMAs).
Automated custodial accounts are now available, which invest a small portion of your disposable income toward your child’s future with each transaction.
In the same way that having a large quantity of money in a 529 plan could affect your child’s eligibility for financial aid, having a significant amount of cash in a custodial account could have the same effect.
Nexym's editorial team handpicks all of the products and services it recommends, regardless of external influences. Affiliate links appear in some of our stories. We may receive an affiliate commission if you purchase something through one of these links, which helps us stay independent and support our great team.